I’ve noticed while grocery shopping that some foods are labeled organic, GMO-free, certified organic, or Non-GMO. As a consumer I think this is very confusing. Do the labels mean different things? Or do they overlap? It’s important to understand what ingredients are in the foods we buy so we can make smart decisions. If a food is organic, does that mean it is also GMO-Free?
It probably won’t surprise you that there is not a simple answer to that question. Nothing about the GMO debate is simple. We make assumptions that if something is organic or Non-GMO that it is guaranteed to be free from genetic engineering. That’s not necessarily true.
To completely understand the difference, you need to get a good grasp on what these terms mean and who makes the rules about them.
I’ve done some research for you and here is what I’ve found.
Who Makes the Organic and GMO-Free Rules
The National Organic Program (NOP) is responsible for developing national standards for organically produced agricultural products. It is housed within the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, and among many other things, maintains a list of certified organic operations, helps farmers and businesses get certified, and manages the National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances.
The Organic Trade Association promotes and protects all that is Organic to “achieve excellence in agriculture and commerce, protect the environment, and enhance community well being.” It represents over 9,500 organic businesses in the US.
NOP-certified organic farmers don’t use genetically modified seed, and have procedures in place that prevent GMO cross contamination from nearby farms. NOP-certified organic processors keep everything separate — organic seeds, feed, crops, ingredients — from the non-organic.
Here’s What These Terms Mean
The USDA defines different “levels” of organic that you need to pay attention to, because sometimes GMOs can sneak their way in.
100% Organic. This means the product contains 100% of organically produced AND completely GMO-free ingredients. Buying something that is labeled 100% certified organic usually ensures that it’s GMO-free. Usually. More on that later.
Certified Organic/USDA Organic. This label means that almost all of the ingredients — 95%–100% — are organic. But there is a small chance (up to 5%) that non-organic ingredients are present in the product. These non-organic ingredients are on a list called the USDA’s National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances. The list does not contain GMOs, but does approve certain synthetic substances for use in organic crop productions, such as alcohols, ethanol, calcium hypochlorite, herbicides and newspaper or other recycled paper. That sounds pretty gross to me, but it is only up to 5%. Does that make a difference to you?
Made with Organic. Since this includes products with only up to 70% organic ingredients, they cannot use the “USDA organic” label. The part that’s NOT organic (30% or more) include substances that would not be allowed in 100% organic products, but they are produced without using generic engineering or other prohibited practices. Whew. Clear as mud?
GMO-Free and Non-GMO. Non-GMOs on an organic product means it’s been produced without technology and without GMO ingredients. GMO-free means its been tested and proven to not contain any GMOs.
Many people use these terms interchangeably, but the difference between the two is often misunderstood and invites a lot of controversy, because not all products are tested all of the time. If the product’s not tested, you can’t be 100% sure it’s completely GMO-Free.
The Skinny on Organic and GMO-Free Foods
A “Non-GMO Project” label and GMO-Free means that it does not contain genetically modified ingredients, but those products may or may not be organic. Stated another way, products that claim to be GMO-Free can be organic or not organic (https://gmo-awareness.com/shopping-list/gmo-free-brands/).
So you can have an organic product that contains no GMOs. Non-GMO does not mean organic, and does not necessarily mean the product is 100% free of GMOs. https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2014/06/20/Non-GMO-not-necessarily-organic-and-other-GMO-myths-busted-OTA
Because of drift and the amount of GMO corn and soybean in neighboring farms that can accidentally cross contaminate, you could potentially have trace amounts of GMOs in non-GMO foods (https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2014/06/20/Non-GMO-not-necessarily-organic-and-other-GMO-myths-busted-OTA) Additionally, trace amounts of GMOs could be found in animal feed from seeds traveling by wind, or by migratory birds that make their home in the soil of an organic farm (https://gmo-awareness.com/2011/05/05/is-organic-always-gmo-free/). So unless the product is tested, you won’t know with 100% certainty if a product is GMO free. (https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2014/06/20/Non-GMO-not-necessarily-organic-and-other-GMO-myths-busted-OTA)
So back to the million dollar question remains: Are organic foods GMO-free? And the answer is: They are supposed to be. But that’s not always what happens. Your best chance at avoiding GMOs is to buy certified USDA organic foods, because they do not intentionally include any GMO ingredients. https://gmo-awareness.com/shopping-list/gmo-free-brands/. This is the best and most easily identifiable way to assure you are eating GMO-free foods — most of the time.
How confident do you feel that 100% certified organic products you buy at the store are GMO-Free? Is it important to you that your foods contain absolutely no trace of GMOs? What are your thoughts about the cross contamination challenges? Are farmers and the USDA doing enough to avoid it? We want to hear your thoughts on this subject! Let the debate begin!